top of page
Blog Posts.jpg
Writer's pictureEthan Justice

Why Granting Citizenship to Undocumented Immigrants Is a Slap in the Face to Legal Immigrants




As a Constitutional Republic, America has always prided itself on being a nation of laws, where the rule of law reigns supreme, and fairness is upheld. For those who dream of becoming part of the great American story, the process of legal immigration is one of the most important pillars. It is a process filled with time, dedication, financial resources, and often, personal sacrifice. Legal immigrants willingly follow this path because they respect the values that underpin the United States Constitution and the structured society it builds.


However, the push to grant citizenship to undocumented immigrants undermines the very principles that legal immigrants strive to uphold. This issue cuts deeply into the hearts of those who respect the legal process and view American citizenship not as a right but as a privilege earned through respect for the laws and traditions of this country.

The Hard Road of Legal Immigrants

Consider the legal immigrant—someone who endures long wait times, fills out countless forms, undergoes background checks, learns English, and often studies for years to pass the naturalization test. These individuals see the United States as a beacon of hope and opportunity, and they are willing to pay the price to join the American experiment.


For them, becoming a citizen means more than just securing a job or enjoying the freedoms of this great country. It’s about being part of a shared cultural and historical legacy. The Founding Fathers laid down a Constitution that fosters freedom, equality, and justice, and legal immigrants are expected to show their respect for this by following the lawful path to citizenship.


When undocumented immigrants are suddenly granted citizenship, it essentially signals that adherence to law is irrelevant. This is not just unfair, but it weakens the integrity of the entire immigration system. If people can come here illegally and still obtain the same rights and privileges as those who spent years trying to follow the law, the incentive to respect the law diminishes. Worse, it sends a message that the process itself is worthless.

Undermining the Rule of Law

Granting citizenship to those who came here illegally is fundamentally a rejection of the rule of law, which is the cornerstone of the American experiment. It diminishes the struggles of legal immigrants and makes their sacrifices seem inconsequential. After all, why would one endure the legal process if bypassing it leads to the same result?


The rule of law is not just a technicality; it is a fundamental principle that ensures fairness and order in society. Undermining this erodes the very fabric of our constitutional republic. We must ask ourselves: what happens when laws lose their meaning?

One must also consider the ripple effect. If the precedent is set that laws governing immigration can be disregarded, what's to stop other laws from being devalued? It opens the door to a more lawless society, where enforcement becomes selective, and equality before the law no longer holds.

A Matter of Fairness

Legal immigrants, as they become citizens, pledge allegiance to the United States and commit to upholding its laws and values. It’s not an easy journey, and the reward is the honor of becoming a part of the American fabric. When undocumented immigrants are granted citizenship, it cheapens the value of that hard-earned status. It’s akin to handing a diploma to someone who never attended class or took the exams, while those who studied diligently and earned their degree watch in disbelief.

This isn't just a question of immigration policy; it's a question of basic fairness. Legal immigrants followed the rules, invested in the process, and made personal sacrifices. They should not be forced to share the same benefits with those who circumvented the system.

A Path Forward

The United States must prioritize policies that reinforce the integrity of its immigration system. Rather than rewarding those who break the law, we should be celebrating and uplifting those who go through the proper channels. America is a nation built on laws, and it must remain so if it is to maintain its greatness.


Legal immigration is part of what makes this country exceptional. Those who come here legally embrace American values and contribute meaningfully to society. Undermining their efforts by offering citizenship to undocumented immigrants does nothing but erode the integrity of the system and insult the law-abiding.


Instead of granting citizenship to those who entered the country illegally, we should focus on reforming our legal immigration system to make it more efficient and accessible. The solution isn’t to discard the rule of law but to strengthen it, ensuring that every future citizen earns their place in this great republic.



26 views0 comments

Comments


  • instagram-xl
  • facebook-3-xl
  • twitter-3-xl
  • youtube-xl
  • telegram-xl
bottom of page